When it comes to our eyebrows, most of us want them to be well groomed, plumped and fleeky. For some people, that means using an eyebrow pencil to create the desired shape and thickness. If you"re in the market for a new best brow pencil, or just want to hear what other people have to say about their favourite brands or their not so favourite read on! On We Are Eves you will find honest reviews from real users of different products and brands. This will surely help you decide which eyebrow pencil is best for you.
The best reviewed Eyebrow pencil products of our community
Latest honest reviews about Eyebrow pencil products
Browse through the latest posts created by the We Are Eves members.
Yes brows baby!
My holy grail for my brows. Application: I’m able to draw super small hairstrokes and it looks super natural. The tip is really fine Quality: product is long lasting, waterproof, humid proof and the only product that lasts all day for me! The color is spot on, not too grey not too warm Tip: you can sharpen the tip by turning the tip back in, just below the plastic. Take a piece of paper and a hard surface, put the product a bit back up and draw stripes on the paper. Result? Super clean tip to make hair like strokes again!
94
Nyx micro brow pencil review
I would say that this is the best brow pencil out there in the beauty market. I started using makeup for my brows at a young age. Because I was always insecure about my brows. So when we talk makeup I know the most about brows and I tried a lot of different things and techniques. Also followed all the latest trends for the eyebrow's. But when I tried the nyx micro brow pencil I was sold. After the nyx I still tried different things but when I look back it is the best product that worked out for my eyebrows. I love the applicator you get the pencil and a spoolie which I love because you don’t have to use two different tools. The micro tip is so easy to use so you can draw your eyebrows very precise. So I would definitely recommend this. 10/10 product
56
Natural eyebrow pencil for a pale gal
The only brow product that has worked for me colour-wise! It has a wide colour range including more cool toned/ashy shades which compliment pale skin very beautifully. The formula looks very natural, especially on already fuller brows, great for quickly filling in and defining the edges lightly. Also, it's really goof-proof! easy to fix up mistakes as it doesn't smear and is very buildable (also pigment brushes out nicely and looks more natural if you overdo it a bit). Got a few friends hooked on it as well, one of my fav makeup products of all time!
187
Pigmentation 5 out of 5!
For a couple of years I've been sold on Benefit for brow products, but I recently I've gotten this pencil and it might push Benefit to the side in the 1st place. It has a great pigmentation, and can be adjusted to be very dark and also very light. It is very easy to fill in the brows. It glides very easily and gives great color. I have red hair and brown pencil is very suitable for me. But maybe it could be a bit lighter, so if I had now burning red now, i'd probably go for auburn color, but I can always adjust pigmentation with how hard I use it.
449
Nice color but not a great performance
I got this pencil for a test. If I would buy it,I could be disappointed. But everything in details: I decided to choose cool tone of brown,and it was perfect for me in a result. What I'm not impressed is how long it stays on a skin.As you can see on photo the tail of my brow just disappeared within few hours. For me it's not OK,I have different pencils,and even cheap from Essence is much better. Will I recommend?no,I believe there is much more different pencils, better than this one. To match my brows is not enough to become my favourite.
487
Kylie convinced me to start using eyebrow pen
I received a Kybrow to test. I am not super much into makeup and was a bit disappointed to find out that this is not an eyeliner. 😉 I usually only use eyeliner and mascara and a bit of lipgloss. But when I tried it, i was super happy! It is easy to apply also for a numpty like me and it gives that bit of extra definition in the look. I applied it softly in the brow and the face just lights up. I tried to capture it in the picture. This product is useful also when you don't regularly pluck your eyebrows. What I would have liked is some instructions on how to apply it well. With eye shadow there is often a manual and different options. I would have loved that for this product as well. I used a simple supermarket eye makeup remover and managed to get everything off. I haven't reached the end of the pencil yet, so can't tell you how long it will keep. Great product to get a little bit of extra definition without too much effort.
255
Kylies brow pencil
I love this product, someone recently gifted it to me and it really helps me shape up my brows!! Apply it to a dark brow and add a concealer under it for a nice look! I definitely recommend using this because it really pops ur brows up!! I love that it has 2 functions in 1
219
THE PERFECT BROWS
I was able to test this product and I am very surprised. The eyebrow pencil is fairly thin, but you can get a good clean line with it. I also really like the packaging, eyebrow pencil lasts all day and is not too dark. I really recommend it.
82
Not very good
I use to love Essence products, but this one I don't like it so much. It's waxy and I have to draw my brows several times in the same place so I can see the color. The thing I like it is that it's automatic, so you don't waste any product. It would be much much better if it would have more pigment and less wax.
165
Pretty decent for the price
Pretty decent for the price. But not that so opaque. It last for 5 hours on me during winter.
158
Maxfactor Brow Shaper
I’d been looking for an easy to use and high quality eye brow product for the longest time, and the @maxfactor brow shaper has been very useful to me! I have dark and thick brows, so my main concern is filling sparse areas. This pencil does the trick as it helps me be precise in my application and the shade is not too dark, allowing my brows to look natural and not overbearing. I’ve used eyebrow pencils with similar twist-up mechanics before, and this is the first where the tip hasn’t been breaking off, which is a huge plus! I’d only wish the tip was even smaller in diameter to be more precise, and better lasting power.
166
Great for subtle brows
EDIT: been using this for a couple weeks and I'm very happy with it! The tone has grown on me and I will definitely be repurchasing. #maxfactor I really like a subtle brow pencil and this worked great! It feels a little waxy on application, but that worked in it's favor, as you can slowly build up your brow. I will most definitely keep using it as my go-to! Gave a minus ⭐ because it is quite cool toned for a deep brown and I tend to prefer a warmer deep color.
159
A big no
Absolutely not worth it… Normally I’m a huge fan of every eyebrow pencil but this, I really don’t like it. It is way too hard and dry. I needed to get over the same spot like 10 times to see just a little bit of color. Will keep trying though. So I’m not giving up. But for now it is a big no
88
Perfect natural brows in seconds!
This is sooooo op good and precise! It looks so natural, very easy to apply and it literally takes a minute to have perfect brows! @maxfactor nailed it with this product!
134
Good cheap option for no fuss brows
Ok so to start off: my brows are ok. Solid, nothing special, a bit sparse here and there but generally passable. So I don't feel like I usually need massive amounts of product and styling to make them look good, but I'm also not one of those ladies blessed by the gods with immaculate and sexy flirty brows. The properties I usually look for in a product are: -long lasting -good color -not too pigmented -precise For the price, I would say cthe Max Factor Brow Shaper is a solid option. Solid, no fuss, does what it promises. If you don't want to commit to a product with a price that'll give you sticker shock, this is your ticket! 1.) However firstly: I'm a dark blonde and I don't like having dark brows, so I always pick the blond or taupe shade. This one has a slightly too strong red undertone for me, where I would have preferred a stronger grey one. But it's not disastrous, given how : 2.) it has a strong wax or equivalent formulation, meaning that the color pay off is quite low. If you are not particularly precise and like using pencils that take a few stroked to really show any pigment, this is right for you. I did not dislike it, but it was still a tad too hard for me. It wasn't problematic though, and I like how the results were very subtle and understated. 3.) I like the fact I don't have to sharpen the point (I always seem to loose pencil sharpeners) and the spoolie at the other end does it's job well. Overall for the price it's a good item especially in a rush, but I would argue that the Kiko Precision Eyebrow Pencil delivers better results for a similar price.
181
Good brow pencil
Really nice colour. I like the application. Easy to apply and lasts long. I tried it with a clear brow gel on top and they worked great together
134
Perfect for small details
The spoolie is actually amazing for brushing and prepping the eyebrows. The tip is also tiny, which makes it great for small touch ups and finishing touches, at least as far as I've used it. @maxfactor @weareeves
44
Max factor brow shaper
Very easy to use. very handy as well. it is a great product when you are on the go. Gives a nice natural effect and long lasting. @maxfactor
97
Natural effect
I love this brow shaper! I am used to natural effect in brows. This is just perfect @maxfactor. I wear it in morning and it lasted for the whole day. What I am impressed the most is the natural effect that it gives (deep brown). I don't like very dark colors on my brow. From now it will be one of my favourites for daily use.
149
almost 3 years ago
I love this! Your eyebrows look amazing
superb
I absolutely love this pencil! The fine tip made me in control of every line I drew and I can gradually decide how thick I want it to be. the brush is really stiff, it gave my eyebrow a nice finish and made them clean and well combed. Finally, I always struggle to find the right color for my eyebrow hair since black is always too dark on me and brown is too light, the MaxFactor color number 20 totally matches my colors. This eyebrow shaper is a must-have in every make I absolutely love this pencil! The fine tip made me in control of every line I drew and I can gradually decide how thick I want it to be. the brush is really stiff, it gave my eyebrow a nice finish and made them clean and well combed. Finally, I always struggle to find the right color for my eyebrow hair since black is always too dark on me and brown is too light, the @maxfactor color number 20 totally matches my colors. This eyebrow shaper is a must-have in every makeup bag!
169