If you’re the type of person who likes to enhance your eyes according to your desires, then you know just how important a good eye pencil is... Buuuut with so many competing brands and different types of eye pencils on the market, from crayon to liquid and even waterproof - it can be increasingly baffling to figure out just which pencil is best for you. That"s where we come in… we"ve collected thousands of raw-and-real user experiences so you can easily decide and make your pick as to which pencil you’re most compatible with! Find your creamy, silky, glide-along-the-eye contour for easy and intuitive application at the *click* of a button - right here, at We Are Eves.
The best reviewed Eye pencil products of our community
Latest honest reviews about Eye pencil products
Browse through the latest posts created by the We Are Eves members.
Great Liquid Eyeliner
Love this eyeliner as the definition is so perfect. Stays on for hours even during workouts without smudging! I will definitely recommend this product and be purchasing it as a standard in my makeup collection. Great intensity of colour and easy to apply with soft but defined brush.
36
Cat-eye masterpiece!
This eyeliner is a game-changer for achieving a beautiful cat eye. The precision brush effortlessly glides across the eyelid, allowing for fine lines and bold wings with remarkable ease. Once applied, the formula dries almost instantly, preventing transfers. The deep, matte black color delivers intense definition to the eyes. I was particularly impressed by the eyeliner's longevity. Even on the hottest, most humid days, it stayed put without any smudging. I really recommend this eyeliner!
68
Irritated my eyes really badly
After using the product I got a bad case of eye redness caused by some severe irritation. I’m no novice to a good eye pencil or kohl, yet I’ve never had a reaction like this before. That aside, for someone that doesn’t react to the ingredients, it’s a good pencil to use. It’s very pigmented and it glides like butter
67
Stays on the whole day
I dont use make-up on the daily but do use it for cosplaying and larping, so I got to try this eyeliner at a shoot. We were shooting in a slight drizzle and the eyeliner didn't go anywhere and stayed where it was. It is easy to apply and when if you made a mistake it's easy removed with a little bit of makeup remover when you just applied. To remove it at the end of the day I used some makeup remover balm and it just melted off without having to scrub it of. So I would definitely recommend this eyeliner
56
The unseen beauty, very dramatic wulfenite
The unseen beauty Spectra shade wulfenite .... Very scary results so great for Halloween 🎃. I thought my sample was cobalt blue so applied and waited for it to change colour. It dried like this , see video ,yes scary ,yes unexpected. Not for me as I don't tend to wear this type of makeup but very vivid red , strong colour and dramatic impact. Not for me but I'm sure plenty of people will love it.
104
about 1 year ago
My rating is merely because I would not purchase the product. I can see that others may really enjoy using this to create more dramatic looks if course. Thank you for your comment .
Dior on stage liner waterproof
To die for! Festival proof, waterproof! Only a crime to take off, but with a good waterproof cleanser youre very good! Fijne intense eyeliner, die doet wat het beloofd, long lasting en zeker waterproof! Holy grail love this!! Het geld zeker waard!
50
Very good, hard to use
Sooo, i liked the product because it stayed on for a pretty dang long time, ofcourse when you rub it in, you won’t get the time as usual for it. One think i will say, it is a bit hard to use, but after some practices it works very well. Its like very soft so you can shape it how you want to. It says it waterproof but i highly doubt it sadly..
64
Pigmented black eye pencil
Such a creamy formula and pigmented product. It’s really black, applies really easily, and feels good on the skin. You can even use it for a cat eyeliner, and because it’s creamy, you van even smudge it out a bit for a more buffed out & smokey look.
126
love it
this is the best longlasting (kohl) pencil. i was on an a 18 hours trip, and the line i draw was still perfect. i am not using this if i like to draw a wing. i prefer to draw it with a eyeliner and not a pencil (maybe i need to learn 😂). also the intensity of the colour is perfect . really loving it
98
Nice eyeliner for a softer look
I got this @maxfactor eyeliner for free to test it. This is a good eyeliner if you like a softer and smudge proof look. Not super pigmented, so don’t expect a bold line from it. It can work for tightlining or for making a subtle winged eye look for makeup beginners who are not experienced with more potent gel or liquid eyeliners. For me personally, I prefer a more intense look, so I had to intensify and seal the eyeliner with some black eyeshadow on top.
141
Broken promises for an eyeliner
I suck doing my eyeliner…it’s true…worst part is that I never had enough patience. So if you promise me to have instant nice eyeliner, I’m all in. Sad part of the story is that the eyeliner was pretty bad itself with the stamp, even worse than myself trying to get eyeliner and sexy foxy eyes.
77
Nice for a pencil liner
Really happy to have received this product as I really needed a black eyeliner. For a pencil liner, it does the job pretty well. It goes on relatively easily (though I do have to draw over the line multiple times), and much like a pencil liner I find it doesn’t last all day long for me - definitely towards the evening I see that the line lacks definition and is a little smudged. But I cannot say I found another pencil liner that does not do this, so it’s not a negative for the product. In general, I am very satisfied. #weareeves @weareeves
125
Bourjois: solid, affordably priced eyeliner
have been using the Bourjois kohl long stay eyeliner daily for about a week now. My usual is Dior waterproof kohl, and this pencil eyeliner does hold its own for a far lower price. How it compares: While the Dior is creamy and no smooth to apply, the Bourjois is a bit harder, more like a classic Kohl pencil (with a tiny bit of flaking during application, so be sure you check for those and brush them away!). The hardness is something for people with soft/sensitive skin to keep in mind. This pencil has good depth of pigmentation (I've been layering it over powder eyeshadow). One thing I like about the Dior version is the opposite end of the pencil has a handy pointed smudger tip, which the Bourjois lacks. In terms of staying power, the Bourjois seems to be comparable. The Bourjois is not truly "all day into the evening" but I have yet to find any pencil eyeliner that is. I used waterproof liquid eyeliner for years because of the lasting power, but that gives a very different effect than pencil, can sometimes look a bit harsh. On the plus side, no difficulty removing this Bourjois eyeliner at the end of the day. Overall, solid addition to the basic makeup bag.
89
it's a pencil
I generally don't use kohl pencils often but this is a pretty typical one in my experience. I wish it were more pigmented, as it pulls kinda grey on the eye. Also, doesn't last well on the waterline (half of the colour faded in around 2 hours). Still, it's fine for adding a bit more definition on the upper lash line and doesn't smudge much if you use it for a small wing. I don't thing it's a product for very dramatic eye looks but works well enough for some smokiness. I received it to test so I'm not sure how expensive it is in comparison with other products but seems decently affordable.
112
Nice eye pencil but weak
The pencil has a nice color and is soft but it fades away quite quickly which is a shame. Other than that it is okay ish compared to other products. Skin type / eyelid may also play a role but on my eyes it didn’t stay for a long time unfortunately
127
a true cool toned grey
There’s not a lot you might want from an eye pencil. It has to be: - pigmented - longlasting - smudge proof - blendable Well this one has it all. I really enjoyed testing it and can see myself purchasing a brown version of it in the future. I received the grey one and it is very dark, almost black, but when you blend it out, it it’s a true cool toned grey. After you applied it, you have some time to work with it before it sets. I used it for winged eyeliner (if you’re curious, I’m wearing it in my previous post on here) and in my waterline. I have no complaints, it does the job well and is super affordable. I checked the price once I received it and at that moment it was 5€ at kruidvat (it was 50%off). Oftentimes there’s a 1+1 promo there as well. So if you need a new trusty eyeliner, I could recommend it!
2418
Not great
I usually use liquid eyeliners, and this product just reminded me why... I drew a straight line but colour was not consistent...it could be my technique but I'm pretty sure I've done it right and still had to repeat over multiple areas in order to get the wanted result - def not the easiest product to use. Furthermore i don't like the tip point,i think should be sharper for more accurate application instead of flat. be careful - if you roll too much product out , there is no way to roll it back in so when you close the lid,pen will break
5335
fine pencil for eyes
I like this pencil, i bought the beige color when it was on sale from kruidvat, I mainly use it for inside of the eye and it works just fine for me. it doesnt go away instantly and it gives a nice color for the inside of my eyes to make them bigger and pop-up.
8292
For lighter skintones mweh
Okay let me be clear. This product is great, for a highlighter on lighter skintones mweh. But damn as a eyeshadow topper or something wow! It shines so good and looks absolutely amazing. The pigment is so high! Gonna try it as highlighter ligthly. Amazing 🥰
7132
almost 2 years ago
Waauw zo shiney 🤩 Maar ik zou t idd niet gebruiken als highlighter met mijn blanke huidje
Gentle oil makeup remover
I love this makeup remover. It’s gentle and doesn’t irritate my skin, while removing heavy makeup, glitter eyeshadows etc. Have been using it for years and love it still! Just like with any oily remover, you need to use other product afterwards to make sure to clear everything away, and I also use a toner in the end before finally moisturising.
212
3 months ago
Rimmel are a great consistent brand 👏🏼 👌🏽