Liquid, waterproof, pencil or cream - whatever look you’re rockin’ mid-week to weekend, there’s no doubt that a quality eyeliner is an indispensable staple to your collection. But with so many different alternatives and brands to choose from - *yikes*, it can be increasingly difficult to know just which one is best for you. Well, that"s where We Are Eves comes in… Here you can read reviews on tons of eyeliner products on the market right now and make better beauty choices based on reviews from real users who’ve already tested, (so you don’t have to!) From the thickest extreme-wear looks to the thinnest long-wear natural liners, get cosy with the Eves community today > read those reviews > and finally get smart at beauty buying.
The best reviewed Eyeliner products of our community
Latest honest reviews about Eyeliner products
Browse through the latest posts created by the We Are Eves members.
So black!
I’ve been using this eye liner for years, it has a really fine felt tip, the eyeliner is very pigmented, with the tip you can draw really sharp lines, very easy to use and it is mess free, not smudge at all and it will stay on all day. For me this is the best and easiest eye liner pen I’ve ever used not to mention the bargain price too.
133
A long wear eyeliner
This is a great ink eye liner. Once it dries it lasts all day. The shape of the nib on this pen is great as it is thin which allows you to make thin or thick lines. I find it really easy to use. The pigmentation is really good, a deep black so you can see it easier.
29
I’m disappointed
When I saw all the commercials on their IG page and the fact that every time was Out of stock in Sephora I wanted it more. And I finally got it. It’s not that pigmented that they claim to be but is indeed transfer proof and it’s matte. I’m a bit disappointed
23
Eye liner
This is hands down the best eye liner I’ve ever used. The colour is so intense it’s so easy to work with and it last all day long without smudging. It’s perfect for the girls that are not that confident in doing their liner because it’s so easy to work with this product
18
26 days ago
Amazing eyeliner. NYX are great! ✨️
Favourite!
This is by far my favourite eyeliner, EVER. I have been using for years and havent found another that i prefer. The black colour is spot on and i personally prefer that it is a loquid, i find the pens dont have the same pigmentation i am looking for. Its a small pot but genuinely lasts a while, it isnt super expensive and in decent price range. Cannot fault this eyeliner at all, easy to clean off and easy to use.
14
Love it!!!
My favourite eye liner!!! I have a very oily skin, so for me it is difficult to find eye liner that stays all day witout smudge. It is a bit expensive and luxury brand , but at least it works for me. I used to try lots of eye liners before, and wasted money for liners, that not worked for me.
10
HOLY GRAIL
if you’re ever considering attempting a graphic eyeliner or maybe a more subtle wing, this is your go to!! great eyeliner tip for struggling beginners and an easy go to for the pros. long lasting, black and smudge proof. what more could you be looking for??
58
Smooth application
Smooth application liner - for most natural results tight line upper lash line underneath top lashes for fuller lashes and definition
41
My number one
This eyeliner is my holy grail. The price is very affordable, the tip is very thin and flexible amd you can draw with precision. The liquid is very pigmented and doesn’t smudge or crack. I simply adore it and repurchase it every time. Definitely worth it
105
Vivid waterproof liner
I was sent this waterproof Red Epic Wear Eye and Body Liner for free in return for my honest review. Wow, wow wow! I've never used red liner before but I am a complete convert. It really appeals to my younger grunge self who adored black and red together. I found it fairly easy to draw with, it is a brush and ink pot type design, so you just redip if you need more product, and I'd suggest wiping it on the pot to start so you don't have too much. It certainly is waterproof! Wow. To the extent its not the easiest thing to remove. I'd suggest have micellar water and cotton buds at the ready for any mistakes and I found the best way to remove once set was to hold a micellar soaked pad over the liner for a bit before wiping to remove. You could definitely trust this to survive the dance floor. Its hard to take a picture of the exact red it is, but I'd say its a blood red colour.
17
Sharp bold lines
Some felt tip pen liners are a little wishy washy, this one is not. It gives a really powerful stark line, which is really stunning. The nib is quite long and pointed, which is a little harder to handle than some but it does allow for some really elegant lines with a bit of practice.
126
super simple!
definitely one of my favorite eyeliners! with having quite hooded eyes, I find it difficult to find products which dry quickly and have a very pointy tip but thankfully this eyeliner does! i would create eyeliner art with this many years back & has never failed me even when I prefer a more subtle wing these days! absolutely a game changer for drugstore makeup. it dries fairly quickly and doesn't budge after applied. I typically blend my eyeshadow first and apply my lashes since I can see where my wing should end, then freehand the rest! also a great tip I've learnt from a friend was to use the pen on my eyelashes band to make everything look more seamless!! 🌱🌙🌷
59
Green with envy
love this pencil and the colour its so pigmented and last for hours and hours! …..one of my favourite colours and pencils, …….amazing value for money, …..glides on effortlessly and doesn’t irritate.. its a must for your make up collection!! Goes beautifully with green eyes
53
Perfect eye pencil
It’s been a while since I decided to purchase a slightly more expensive eye pencil to complete my everyday look. I purchased the product in shade of shimmery brown and it is the perfect eye pencil. It is very creamy and thus applies easily, but doesn’t randomly smudge and stays in place. Apart from that, the colour is very flattering.
88
Worst eyeliner I have bought
It might just have been my product but I didn’t really get any product on the brush to use. Tried shaking it and constant dipping but not really getting anything on the brush. What I did get was a very thick product which was not easy to get precise lines with
105
Meh
This a good mascara however for me I have rather short straight eyelashes. This mascara just made them look darker didn’t help with any volume and made my eyelashes look clumpy. My eyes are rather sensitive so this isn’t my go to mascara however I do hear it is amazing for others
40
My holy grail!
I’ve tried so many different eyeliners but this one has always come out on top! It’s so versatile, you can use it in your waterline, it’s super easy to get a clean wing, or if you fancy a smudged look it’s super easy to smudge into a lovely Smokey look! It doesn’t budge or transfer all day either
38
Good but I’ve used better for my eye shape
This eyeliner is good, it’s a flick type liner which is easy enough to apply, the eyeliner is not too wet and it doesn’t dry out. It’s a great eyeliner but I have seen better, but for someone beginning liquid eyeliner then this is a good one. Specifically I like that the tip isn’t a thin straight point rather it’s small but like a pointed paintbrush. This makes it easier to apply. My only downfall is the size of the tip, I prefer eyeliners with tips’ that are slightly larger.
44
Great eyeliner
This eyeliner is ultra-black, waterproof and stays up to 24h. The brush is so flexible and ultra thin so you can draw your perfect and thin eyeliner. It’s so easy to work it. It’s a long-lasting formula that has Coconut water combined with other ingredients which moisture the lashes and have a matte finish. And the price is super affordable. You need to try it. I am so happy with it 😁
93
Literally the best eyeliner I’ve ever used
This eyeliner is so underrated. It’s my favourite out of all the eyeliner I’ve used before. The liner itself is like a thin brush pen but the applicator makes it easier to apply liner on my hooded eyes in comparison to a paintbrush like liner end. The shape is perfect and the applicator is the right wetness. I say this because often with eyeliners I find them too wet, or smudgy, or hard to apply especially on very hooded eyes. Love this eyeliner so much.
518
14 days ago
Lovely 💗